Be careful about who is attacking teachers...

Please read:

http://www.commondreams.org/view/2011/03/28-11

Or a few exerts:

"Test-based teacher evaluation systems have the potential to seriously damage the teaching profession. The National Academy of Sciences found 20 to 30 percent error rates in “value-added” ratings systems based on their own dubious premises. Teachers in the bottom group one year were often in the top group the next and vice versa. The same teachers measured by two different standardized tests produced completely inconsistent results. The basic assumptions of these testing systems are at odds with the way real schools actually work. Bending school practices to accommodate them could negatively affect everything from the way students are assigned to classes to the willingness of teachers to serve high-needs populations and the collaborative professional culture that good schools depend on for success."

"It took well over a hundred years to create a public school system that, for all its flaws, provides a free education for all children as a legal right. It took campaigns against child labor, crusades for public taxation, struggles against fear and discrimination directed at immigrants, historic movements for civil rights against legally sanctioned separate and unequal schooling, movements for equal rights and educational access for women, and in more recent decades sustained drives for the rights of special education students, gay and lesbian students, bilingual students, and Native American students. These campaigns are all unfinished and the gains they’ve made are uneven and fragile. But they have made public schools one of the last places where an increasingly diverse and divided population still comes together for a common civic purpose.

But the system’s Achilles’ heel continues to be acute racial and class inequality, which in fact is the Achilles’ heel of the whole society."

We need to be careful about those who call for educational reform. Many are out for profit through privatization of schools, but we must stand up for equal access and equitable resources for all of our children. Free and fair access to public education should be the cornerstone of our society.

What frustrates me most when reading this article is that if we truly valued our kids future and their education then our country would have no debate over education reform. It would end at, "every student, every teacher, every school, will have the full support of every person in the country." If we truly wanted a healthy, successful country our schools should be funded well beyond their needs and our teachers shouldn't have to worry about being judged on merit based systems based on standardized testing that doesn't properly judge students achievement.

None-the-less, what can be taken out of this is that the US education system is at a crucial point...as I'm sure has been said many times before. What will come of this latest move for reform? Increased class sizes to increase market efficiency? If so you can count me out. I'll start my own school here in Guatemala with small class sizes and strong teacher to student connection. Because anyone whose taken an upper-level college class with 10 other students knows the value of small class sizes.

Peace,
LP